Essay plan – explain Anselm’s ontological argument

OCR Part a – Explain Anselm’s Ontological Argument (25)

Part b – “Gaunilo’s challenge undermines Anselm.” Discuss

Introduction

  • What is the context of Anselm’s ontological argument?
  • What is the question asking you to do?
  • What fields of knowledge are you going to explore?

Main body

1. Analytic and synthetic knowledge

  • What is meant by analytic? Give examples of analytic knowledge
  • What is meant by synthetic? Give examples of synthetic knowledge
  • What is the strength and weakness of each type?

2. Version 1 – in the Proslogion

  • Psalm 14: What does it discuss?
  • The Fool: What makes him a fool according to Anselm?
  • TTWNGCBC: What is Anselm’s definition of God? How does he arrive at it?
  • Greatness: Existing in the mind alone or reality and the mind.
  • Conclusion: The Ontological Argument 1.
  • Denial: Why Anselm says it’s foolish to deny it.
  • Painter: Anselm’s example of the painter and the painting existing in the mind and then in reality.

3. Version 2 – Anselm’s Apologetic to Gaunilo

  • TTWNGCBC: The importance of that definition and the challenge presented by Gaunilo.
  • Contingent: What is meant by contingent things?
  • Necessary: What is meant by necessary things?
  • Greatness: How is God necessary by definition?
  • Conclusion: The Ontological Argument 2.

(b) Gaunilo’s challenge undermines Anselm (10)

Introduction

  • What is the context of Gaunilo’s challenge?
  • What is the question asking you to do?
  • What fields of knowledge are you going to explore?

Main body

  • Agreeing with statement/Disagreeing with statement.
  • Why Gaunilo is right.
  • Why Gaunilo is wrong.
  • Who supports Gaunilo? eg Hume, Kant.
  • Who challenges Gaunilo/agrees with Anselm? eg Norman, Plantinga etc.

Conclusion

  • Summarising what you have said and drawing your own conclusion.

 

Presentations

Handouts

Extracts

Articles

Media

Revision

Past Questions

Disclaimer. Inducit Learning Ltd. is not responsible for any content outside of the pushmepress.com domain. If you are a rights holder and you think we have breached your copright, please email the editor and we will remove it.